Elmhurst Menu
- Appetizers
- Pizzas
- Gourmet Pizzas
- The Flip It Pizza
- Stuffed & Pan Pizzas
- Calzones
- Pastas
- Fresh Salads
- Create Your Own Salad
- Sandwiches
- Drinks & Desserts
Appetizers
Bread Sticks 2.99
Cheesy Bread 4.99
Pizza Bread 2.99
Garlic Bread 2.99
ChickenWings (6) 5.99 • (12) 8.99
Available Plain, Frank’s Original Hot Sauce, Mild, Sweet Baby Ray® BBQ Sauce
or Honey Mustard. Served with either blue cheese or ranch, celery & carrot sticks
Boneless Chicken Bites (6) 4.59 • (12) 7.59
Mozzarella Sticks (5) 5.99 • (10) 10.99
Jalapeño Poppers (6) 5.99 • (12) 10.99
Fried Mushrooms 4.99
French Fries 1.99
Onion Rings 3.99
Homemade Jumbo Garlic Knots (6) 2.99 • (13) 5.99
Homemade tossed with fresh minced garlic, extra virgin olive oil & fresh parmesan cheese, topped with parsley.
Soup
(Cup) 2.99 • (Quart) 8.99
Ask cashier for today's specials
» Return To The Top
Pizzas
Our Classic New York-Style (Thin Crust) Pizzas.
We use Grande provolone cheese blend!
12" 14" 16" 18"
Create Your Own Pizza! 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00
Start with a cheese pizza
Each Additional Ingredient 1.25 1.50 1.75 2.00
Pizza Toppings
Veggies: Artichoke Hearts • Broccoli • Garlic • Mushrooms • Onions • Black Olives • Green Olives • Kalamata Olives • Green Peppers • Red Peppers • Jalapeños • Giardiniera Spinach • Tomatoes • Sun-Dried Tomatoes • Pineapple • Basil
Cheeses: Cheddar • Feta • Ricotta • Fresh Mozzarella/Provolone Blend
Meat: Sausage • Pepperoni • Bacon • Canadian Bacon • Ham • Chicken • Ground Beef • Italian Beef • Salami • Gyro
» Return To The Top
Gourmet Pizzas
Our Classic New York-Style (Thin Crust) Pizzas. We use Grande mozzarella/provolone cheese blend!
Prices below are for the following sizes: Slice, 12", 14", 16", 18"
Cheese
3.19 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00
Fresh Grande® mozzarella with a touch of romano & parmesan cheese
Sausage
3.99 13.25 15.50 17.75 20.00
Fresh Grande®mozzarella & fresh Italian sausage with a hint of oregano
Pepperoni
3.99 13.25 15.50 17.75 20.00
Fresh Grande®mozzarella & pepperoni with a hint of oregano
The Garbage
4.59 16.00 18.00 22.00 26.00
Sausage, pepperoni, green pepper, onion & mushrooms all piled high on this crisp thin crust
The Big Meaty
4.59 16.00 18.00 22.00 26.00
Bacon, sausage, pepperoni, ground beef, Italian beef & fresh Grande®mozzarella
BBQ Chicken
3.99 14.00 16.00 18.00 23.00
Light BBQ sauce instead of traditional pizza sauce, BBQ chicken, sweet onions, mozzarella & cheddar cheeses, sprinkled with fresh cilantro
Chicken Parmesan
n/a 14.00 16.00 18.50 23.00
Fresh plum tomato sauce & blended mozzarella topped with strips of hand breaded chicken breast & savory red onions
The Veggie
n/a 15.00 17.00 21.00 25.00
A blend of our freshest veggies! Great for vegetarians or those who want a healthy kick to their pizza
Chicken Alfredo
n/a 14.00 16.00 18.00 23.00
Ranch dressing instead of traditional pizza sauce, grilled chicken & fresh mozzarella
Margherita
n/a 14.00 16.00 18.00 22.00
This tasty authentic pizza is made with plum tomato sauce, slices of fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil & garden fresh basil
Bruschetta
n/a 14.00 16.00 18.00 22.00
This original, exclusive to Pauly's Pizza-Ria, starts with a sauce-less garlic & parmesan crust topped with a 4 cheese blend of mozzarella,
provolone, parmesan & romano with fresh
bruschetta (served cold on the side for topping
or dipping). The bruschetta is made with the
finest&freshest ingredients: tomatoes, red onions,
fresh garlic & fresh basil. You have to try this
pizza, it just might be the best on the planet!
The Mexican
n/a 15.00 17.00 19.00 23.00
A sauce-less pizza replaced with tasty chili topped with sausage, onions, tomato, jalapeños, fresh mozzarella & cheddar cheese, garnished with cilantro.
Manhattan
n/a 15.00 17.00 19.00 23.00
Grilled chicken, broccoli, ricotta, romano & fresh mozzarella
The Beach Body
n/a 12.00 14.00 16.00 18.00
(Very Low-Fat) Cheese-less veggie pizza with grilled vegetables, herbs & tomato sauce
The Hula
n/a 14.00 16.00 18.50 23.00
Traditional pizza sauce, fresh mozzarella, smoked ham & diced pineapple
Get CheesyWith It
n/a 15.00 17.00 19.00 23.00
Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, a touch of romano & parmesan cheese
The Divine
n/a 15.00 17.00 21.00 25.00
Bacon, sausage, green peppers & onions all piled high on a thin & crispy crust
White Pizza
n/a 14.00 16.00 18.00 22.00
No red sauce. Olive oil & garlic topped with fresh mozzarella, red onions & sliced tomatoes
Gyro Pizza
n/a 15.00 17.00 19.00 23.00
Tzatziki sauce to start & blended mozzarella topped with thinly sliced gyro meat, sliced tomatoes & white onions
Buffalo Chicken
n/a 15.00 17.00 19.00 23.00
This specialty pizza starts off with your choice of ranch or blue cheese dressing instead of
traditional pizza sauce topped with strips of grilled chicken tossed in our savory Buffalo sauce, sliced red onion & fresh celery then smothered in mozzarella & cheddar cheeses
Popeye
4.59 15.00 17.00 19.00 23.00
This creation begins with traditional pizza sauce, spinach, mushrooms & sliced tomatoes. Finally smothered in mozzarella & feta cheese. A sprinkle of garlic tops this delectable original
Pauly’s Special
n/a 15.00 17.00 19.00 23.00
This creation begins with traditional pizza sauce topped with generous portions of sausage, mushrooms & bacon. Finally, it is smothered in mozzarella & parmesan cheese. A sprinkle of oregano tops this delicious pie
» Return To The Top
The Flip It Pizza
Take our Classic New York-Style pizza & Flip It! Start with the dough, then add our delicious Grande® cheese, then add a layer of ingredients & top it all with our homemade pizza sauce. It's the best pizza you'll ever order! A unique way to get your pizza.
Stuffed & Pan Pizzas
Made with a delicious garlic butter crust. Please allow 45 minutes for cooking
10" 12"
Cheese 13.00 17.00
Fresh Grande® mozzarella/provolone cheese blend on the bottom, your choice of ingredients
in the middle & topped with our special homemade pizza sauce
Ingredients (ea) 2.00, 2.50
Pizza Toppings
Veggies: Artichoke Hearts • Broccoli • Garlic • Mushrooms • Onions • Black Olives • Green Olives • Kalamata Olives • Green Peppers • Red Peppers • Jalapeños • Giardiniera Spinach • Tomatoes • Sun-Dried Tomatoes • Pineapple • Basil
Cheeses: Cheddar • Feta • Ricotta • Fresh Mozzarella/Provolone Blend
Meat: Sausage • Pepperoni • Bacon • Canadian Bacon • Ham • Chicken • Ground Beef • Italian Beef • Salami • Gyro
» Return To The Top
Calzones
All Calzones are made with our Grande mozzarella cheese & served with a side of marinara
2 Ingredients 6.95
4 Ingredients 8.95
The Veggie 8.49
A blend of all our freshest veggies! Great for vegetarians or those who want a healthy kick to their calzone
The Divine 8.49
Bacon, sausage, green peppers & onions stuffed inside our mouth-watering calzone
The Big Meaty 8.49
Bacon, sausage, pepperoni, ground beef, Italian beef & fresh mozzarella cheese
The Hula 8.49
Traditional pizza sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, smoked ham & diced juicy pineapple
» Return To The Top
Pastas
All Pasta Entrées are served with marinara sauce & our homemade garlic bread
Baked Mosticolli 7.99
Our mosticolli smothered in
provolone cheese & baked to perfection
Spaghetti or Mosticolli 6.99
Cheese or Meat Ravioli 7.99
Rigatoni Vodka Sauce 8.99
Linguini Garlic & Oil 6.99
8 Finger Cavatelli 9.99
Served in vodka sauce
Manicotti 9.99
Add Meat Sauce for 1.00
Add Sausage or Chicken for 2.00
Add Meatballs for 3.00
» Return To The Top
Fresh Salads
Dressings: Honey Mustard • Blue Cheese • Creamy Caesar • Balsamic Vinaigrette • Italian • Ranch • Fat Free Raspberry Vinaigrette • Sesame Thai • Creamy Garlic • French
Extra Dressing for 50¢
Garbage 8.99
Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumber, artichoke hearts, hearts of palm, chicken,
salami, Kalamata olives, pepperoni, egg, bacon, red onions, blue cheese, croutons & savory ranch dressing
BBQ Chicken 8.49
Mixed greens topped with BBQ chicken strips, cheddar cheese, corn, black beans,
crunchy tortilla strips, diced tomatoes, avocado, cilantro & savory ranch dressing
Oriental Chicken 8.49
Mixed greens, crisp red & green peppers, almonds, Mandarin oranges, chow mein noodles & tender grilled chicken served with Thai sesame dressing
Hula 8.49
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, cucumber, tomatoes, red peppers, pineapple & walnuts. Served with balsamic vinaigrette dressing
Cobb 8.49
Mixed greens, avocado, juicy grilled chicken,boiled egg, bacon & tomatoes. Served with balsamic vinaigrette dressing
Divine 8.49
This is a delicious treat starting with hearts of romaine or baby greens, grilled chicken breast, huge chunks of bacon, cucumber, red onions, croutons, boiled egg & corn. Served with creamy garlic dressing
Greek 8.49
This delicious Mediterranean favorite starts with romaine lettuce topped with tomato,
artichoke, cucumber, red onion, red pepper, Kalamata olives & feta cheese. Served with our amazing Greek vinaigrette
Side House 1.99
Caesar 6.49
Romaine lettuce, croutons & parmesan
cheese. Served with creamy Caesar dressing
Add Chicken 2.00
Taco 8.49
This South of the border delight starts with a bed of romaine lettuce topped with ground
beef, red cherry tomatoes, yummy cheddar cheese, jalapeño peppers, sour cream, avocado,
cilantro & tortilla strips. Served with savory ranch dressing
Create Your Own Salad - 4.99
Choose from either romaine or mixed baby greens to start & add up to 5 ingredients from our abundant list
Ingredients
Artichoke Hearts • Broccoli • Avocado • Egg Mushrooms • Onions • Red Onions • Corn Crispy Tortilla Strips • Black Olives • Green Olives • Kalamata Olives • Jalapeños • Green Peppers • Red Peppers • Cucumber Tomatoes • Sun-Dried Tomatoes • Pineapple Mandarin Oranges • Chow Mein Noodles • Walnuts
Additional Veggie (ea) .25
Cheese
Cheddar • Romano • Mozzarella
Feta • Parmesan
Additional Cheese (ea) .50
Meat
Chicken 2.00 • BBQ Chicken 2.00
Salami 1.50 • Bacon 1.50 • Pepperoni 1.50
Ham 1.50 • Tuna Salad 1.50
» Return To The Top
Sandwiches
All Sandwiches are served hot with crinkle cut French fries or a side salad. Substitute waffle fries for .50
Italian Beef or Sausage 4.99
Served on French bread with au jus on the side for dipping
Italian Combo 6.50
Served on French bread with au jus on the side for dipping
Chicken Breast 5.49
Grilled chicken breast served with lettuce, tomato, pickle & mayo on a bun
BBQ Beef 4.99
Our delicious sliced roast beef smothered in BBQ sauce, served on French bread
Meatball 5.50
Three giant homemade meatballs, smothered with marinara on French bread
Black Angus Burger & Fries 5.49
Served with your choice of cheese, white onion, lettuce & tomato
Maxwell St. Polish 4.99
Smothered in onions & served with fries
Buffalo Chicken 5.49
Grilled chicken breast tossed in Buffalo sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese. Served on French bread
BBQ Chicken 5.49
Fresh chicken breast smothered in Sweet Baby Ray® BBQ sauce, topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce & tomato. Served on French bread
Godfather 6.50
Italian beef sandwich with melted cheese served on garlic French bread with a side of au jus for dipping
Godmother 6.50
Fresh chicken breast sandwich served with marinara sauce, then smothered with mozzarella cheese, served on garlic bread
Add-Ons
Add any of these items to any Sandwich to make it even better!
On Garlic Bread .75 • Add Giardiniera .30
Add Sweet Peppers .30 • Add Jalapeños .30
Add Marinara .30 • Add Cheese .50
(Provolone, American or cheddar)
Add Au Jus Free!
» Return To The Top
Drinks & Desserts
Soda 20 oz 1.49 • 1 Liter 1.99
We proudly serve Coke® products
Lezza® Italian Ice
Small 3.00 Large 5.00
Jumbo Brownies 1.99
Eli’s® Cheesecake 2.99
Homemade Cannoli
Chocolate Chip or Pistachio
Mama 2.99 Baby .99
